HSC Physics Predictions / Thoughts (1 Viewer)

JeydinNewWon

Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2017
Messages
49
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
For question 20, there has been disputes over where it is A) or D). But I think I have a definitive case for why it is, in fact, A. When the ball undergoes a projectile-ish motion with the semi-circular ramp, it has both horizontal and vertical velocity components, right?

However! the centripetal force has a velocity component that is PERPENDICULAR to it. Considering the centripetal force is the Normal, this means the horizontal velocity component of the "projectile path" must be the velocity in the centripetal force, hence the centripetal force must be constant.

Also, remember, the centripetal force cannot have a velocity that is not constant--I don't think that makes sense.

So I'm a bit confused as to why MATRIX has set Q20 as D).
 

NN03

New Member
Joined
Jan 14, 2020
Messages
19
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
For question 20, there has been disputes over where it is A) or D). But I think I have a definitive case for why it is, in fact, A. When the ball undergoes a projectile-ish motion with the semi-circular ramp, it has both horizontal and vertical velocity components, right?

However! the centripetal force has a velocity component that is PERPENDICULAR to it. Considering the centripetal force is the Normal, this means the horizontal velocity component of the "projectile path" must be the velocity in the centripetal force, hence the centripetal force must be constant.

Also, remember, the centripetal force cannot have a velocity that is not constant--I don't think that makes sense.

So I'm a bit confused as to why MATRIX has set Q20 as D).
I legit got a lucky guess and put A as the answer. God was with me on that one.
 

wizzkids

Active Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2016
Messages
253
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
1998
2020 HSC Physics
MC Question 16 (the fission reactor question)
There seems to be bit of confusion on this forum about the speed of fission neutrons. In a typical atomic fission, the velocity of the neutrons is around 1 MeV (or about 10^7 metres per second). In order to interact effectively with the nucleus, their velocity (and hence their de Broglie matter wavelength) needs to be slowed to about 0.02 MeV. At these speeds, they almost in thermal equilibrium with their surroundings, and hence, they are referred to as "thermal neutrons". That is what the moderator does, it absorbs the momentum of the 1 MeV neutrons through multiple elastic collisions, until they are in thermal equilibrium with their surroundings. Anyway, the correct answer is (A) withdraw the control rods.
 

fysiqs

New Member
Joined
May 6, 2018
Messages
20
Gender
Female
HSC
2010
A 91-92 raw could still align to like a 96 cause it was so hard. That’s what I’m aiming for 😂
You honestly have no idea about marks. A raw mark, as in a truly raw mark without school moderation, of 70% will be alligned to very high 80's. A raw mark of 91 would put you in the top 20 inthe state and would be given as 98 -99. The average RAWMARK in a physics exam is approx 55 in a good year. Just an fyi.
 

Speed’o’sound Sonic

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2019
Messages
495
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
You honestly have no idea about marks. A raw mark, as in a truly raw mark without school moderation, of 70% will be alligned to very high 80's. A raw mark of 91 would put you in the top 20 inthe state and would be given as 98 -99. The average RAWMARK in a physics exam is approx 55 in a good year. Just an fyi.
Guess we’ll find out 🤷🏻‍♂️ Props to you though mate
 

fysiqs

New Member
Joined
May 6, 2018
Messages
20
Gender
Female
HSC
2010
View attachment 29434

If you guys still care about that exam, MC answers from High School Physics Explained are uploaded
I think this guy might be in trouble with NESA. As one of the senior markers in physics, there is the hilarious situation that he actually got some of these wrong. More worryingly, as a senior marker, he should not have discussed these answers with he general public, its actually against the rules of being a marker to discuss HSC marking and to do this before the marking begins is a big no-no.so I'm told.......... Especially with poor kids doing the chem exam today, they would be be annoyed at listening to his answers. Seems like he has caught the youtube bug of trying to be first with his "review". Hopefully Kerry Sheehan of NESA never finds out
 

Speed’o’sound Sonic

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2019
Messages
495
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
I think this guy might be in trouble with NESA. As one of the senior markers in physics, there is the hilarious situation that he actually got some of these wrong. More worryingly, as a senior marker, he should not have discussed these answers with he general public, its actually against the rules of being a marker to discuss HSC marking and to do this before the marking begins is a big no-no.so I'm told.......... Especially with poor kids doing the chem exam today, they would be be annoyed at listening to his answers. Seems like he has caught the youtube bug of trying to be first with his "review". Hopefully Kerry Sheehan of NESA never finds out
Chill
 

Esdog07

New Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2019
Messages
9
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
For question 20, there has been disputes over where it is A) or D). But I think I have a definitive case for why it is, in fact, A. When the ball undergoes a projectile-ish motion with the semi-circular ramp, it has both horizontal and vertical velocity components, right?

However! the centripetal force has a velocity component that is PERPENDICULAR to it. Considering the centripetal force is the Normal, this means the horizontal velocity component of the "projectile path" must be the velocity in the centripetal force, hence the centripetal force must be constant.

Also, remember, the centripetal force cannot have a velocity that is not constant--I don't think that makes sense.

So I'm a bit confused as to why MATRIX has set Q20 as D).
Ye that was my reasoning as well
 

wizzkids

Active Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2016
Messages
253
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
1998
Matrix Education released their 2020 HSC Physics answers up if anyone is interested
In my humble opinion, I disagree with Matrix explanation for MCQ 20 being (D). The essence of the problem is that horizontal and vertical components of motion can be independently analysed. The vertical component of motion is subjected to only the constant gravitational force; on this point everyone seems to agree. The horizontal motion takes place in the horizontal plane, and it is uniform circular motion, around a path of constant radius. The centripetal acceleration and the centripetal force are towards the centre of curvature, and are constant. It is a logical error to say that a reduction in the vertical velocity will lower the centripetal acceleration - they are orthogonal. The final step, vector addition of the two force vectors, which are orthogonal. The magnitude of the resultant force is constant (but it's direction is constantly changing). (A) is correct
 

black.mamba

Active Member
Joined
May 15, 2020
Messages
213
Location
Vern Gang
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
I think this guy might be in trouble with NESA. As one of the senior markers in physics, there is the hilarious situation that he actually got some of these wrong. More worryingly, as a senior marker, he should not have discussed these answers with he general public, its actually against the rules of being a marker to discuss HSC marking and to do this before the marking begins is a big no-no.so I'm told.......... Especially with poor kids doing the chem exam today, they would be be annoyed at listening to his answers. Seems like he has caught the youtube bug of trying to be first with his "review". Hopefully Kerry Sheehan of NESA never finds out
Wait damn what happened?? I couldn't find his vid yesterday, thought sth was up. Kinda feel bad for him bc i used his vids a lot throughout the past year.

Also which questions did he get wrong?
 

JeydinNewWon

Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2017
Messages
49
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
Wait damn what happened?? I couldn't find his vid yesterday, thought sth was up. Kinda feel bad for him bc i used his vids a lot throughout the past year.

Also which questions did he get wrong?
That's strange. He must've deleted it or it had to be taken down. Still, his logic was correct in the multiple choice, especially with Question 20.
 

Speed’o’sound Sonic

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2019
Messages
495
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
Isn't NESA ironically validating his own answers at that point? Makes sense, this year's exams have been...weird to say the least.
Oath. NESA has been super weird this year, and along with all the outages in ScienceExt they’ll have a very tough time marking this year. Hopefully it all works out fine though.
 

JeydinNewWon

Member
Joined
Oct 28, 2017
Messages
49
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
Oath. NESA has been super weird this year, and along with all the outages in ScienceExt they’ll have a very tough time marking this year. Hopefully it all works out fine though.
I managed to find an unlisted link to the video. Turns out he took it down due him being a senior marker of Physics. This means his answers are qualified. He may not be an exam writer but his answers are definitely have the logic and he has qualified many years of Physics teaching experience.
 

Speed’o’sound Sonic

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 4, 2019
Messages
495
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
I managed to find an unlisted link to the video. Turns out he took it down due him being a senior marker of Physics. This means his answers are qualified. He may not be an exam writer but his answers are definitely have the logic and he has qualified many years of Physics teaching experience.
That’s interesting to hear. I wonder why they took the video down 😂 seems super odd... who knows? 🤷🏻‍♂️
 

Fabrizio

Active Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2019
Messages
141
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
In my humble opinion, I disagree with Matrix explanation for MCQ 20 being (D). The essence of the problem is that horizontal and vertical components of motion can be independently analysed. The vertical component of motion is subjected to only the constant gravitational force; on this point everyone seems to agree. The horizontal motion takes place in the horizontal plane, and it is uniform circular motion, around a path of constant radius. The centripetal acceleration and the centripetal force are towards the centre of curvature, and are constant. It is a logical error to say that a reduction in the vertical velocity will lower the centripetal acceleration - they are orthogonal. The final step, vector addition of the two force vectors, which are orthogonal. The magnitude of the resultant force is constant (but it's direction is constantly changing). (A) is correct
You guys need to relax with this. Doesnt matter how many times you explain it, its not going to change NESA's answer when it comes out
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top