HSC Extension 1 Mathematics Predictions / Thoughts (2 Viewers)

erucibon

Active Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2018
Messages
210
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
Yes, q14a is challenging but I believe that the difficulty of this paper has been overstated a little compared to past years, given the other parts are somewhat easier (and even 14a to it's equivalent). I would expect a borderline band 5-6 student to lose around 7 marks on question 14 (either 6+1 Or 5+2) and no more than 2 marks on each of the other sections and one mark on multiple choice (Q9 most likely). So far from being extremely easy or anything, but in my opinion just a bit more approachable than past years.
it was definitely easier than previous years in my opinion
 

Husky

Active Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2019
Messages
108
Gender
Male
HSC
2019
it was definitely easier than previous years in my opinion
yeah I agree as well. Although I don't think last years paper was that difficult (besides 3 marks at the end) but the cut off was still low so I predict it will be low this year as well. Also this forum makes up 1% of students so it doesn't reflect how the rest of the state did with the exam.
 

erucibon

Active Member
Joined
Jul 2, 2018
Messages
210
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
I think the consensus is that it was difficult/moderate for the average student because of the perms and combs and also because there was no projectile, but top students would have found it very easy, apart from the rigour in proving the equal functions and the last part of the combs question. There will be a large concentration of marks at 68-70 probably.
 

Husky

Active Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2019
Messages
108
Gender
Male
HSC
2019
I think the consensus is that it was difficult/moderate for the average student because of the perms and combs and also because there was no projectile, but top students would have found it very easy, apart from the rigour in proving the equal functions and the last part of the combs question. There will be a large concentration of marks at 68-70 probably.
I think 13c) for the f(x) = g(x) will ruin a lot of potential state rankers. Quite a nice question actually and I think barely any considered both sides of the domain, even ruiace on atar notes missed it.
 

Xanthi

Active Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2020
Messages
208
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2020
yeah I agree as well. Although I don't think last years paper was that difficult (besides 3 marks at the end) but the cut off was still low so I predict it will be low this year as well. Also this forum makes up 1% of students so it doesn't reflect how the rest of the state did with the exam.
Making a direct comparison between last year, the last at least 11 of last year's 12 marks look somewhat harder than 14a this year. I'd imagine the b6 cutoff for those twelve marks would be 1/12. Last year's cutoff of around 52 leaves 7 marks remaining deducted elsewhere. Adding this on to 7 marks for this year's q14 gives my estimate of 56 (assuming the rest of the paper is similar difficulty).
 

Xanthi

Active Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2020
Messages
208
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2020
I think the consensus is that it was difficult/moderate for the average student because of the perms and combs and also because there was no projectile, but top students would have found it very easy, apart from the rigour in proving the equal functions and the last part of the combs question. There will be a large concentration of marks at 68-70 probably.
I think you are right about this. There will large concentration of 67-69 marks, but the number of 70 marks will purely depend on the mark scheme for f(x)=g(x). If full marks requires recognition of derivative domain and testing of four points, I cannot imagine more than single digit number of 70 marks.
 

Husky

Active Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2019
Messages
108
Gender
Male
HSC
2019
Making a direct comparison between last year, the last at least 11 of last year's 12 marks look somewhat harder than 14a this year. I'd imagine the b6 cutoff for those twelve marks would be 1/12. Last year's cutoff of around 52 leaves 7 marks remaining deducted elsewhere. Adding this on to 7 marks for this year's q14 gives my estimate of 56 (assuming the rest of the paper is similar difficulty).
again you're basing that off of students that are from this forum that would have found it easy. The judges who decide the cut off would be considering the whole state not just a handful of students, and also new syllabus cut offs are usually lower as seen from last years new syllabus papers which all had low cut offs even though some of them weren't difficult.
 

Xanthi

Active Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2020
Messages
208
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2020
again you're basing that off of students that are from this forum that would have found it easy. The judges who decide the cut off would be considering the whole state not just a handful of students, and also new syllabus cut offs are usually lower as seen from last years new syllabus papers which all had low cut offs even though some of them weren't difficult.
If you are referring 7/15 for q14 (given the rest was estimated from last year's judges decision), I find it hard to imagine a cutoff below 2-3/8 as the first part was a relatively standard binomial style question and quite similar questions have occurred before. Maybe you are right that the 5-6/7 is too high for the last question due to the last part - I agree that 4-5/7 might be more suitable giving a 55 cutoff.

Edit: this estimation is based the difficulty compared to last year's judges decision. Additionally I think this forum while not representative of the average student for sure, does give a sense of the band 5-6 student, which would be quite a bit better than average

Regarding the new syllabus, the sciences mark schemes are entirely different and based more on explaining rather than solving, so it is not directly comparable.
 
Joined
Oct 31, 2020
Messages
74
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
I doubt it will deviate far from a 55 because i would say about 8 marks from q14 would be considered band 6 and then you have the 7 for the f(x)=g(x) and then the volume of revolution.
agreed, those were the most problematic for me, but do we also count stupid errors in working out and 1-2 missed mc qs?
personally i found the mc, q11 and 12 p easy BUT ofc you always have to subtract stupid errors marks in working etc
 
Joined
Oct 31, 2020
Messages
74
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
also we gotta remember that the range for an e4 in ext1 maths is MASSIVE, it covers 39% of all ppl taking the test (based on last years hsc scaling report), i think this should be a factor too
 

Fabrizio

Active Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2019
Messages
141
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
Even though like 14a) i was relatively standard, most people would of still gotten it wrong because it doesnt come up in many trial papers and then even in the textbooks it isnt covered. Smarter maths compiles all the questions from past hsc and in the binomial chapter even they only have 1 question that is somewhat similar to it
 

Xanthi

Active Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2020
Messages
208
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2020
also we gotta remember that the range for an e4 in ext1 maths is MASSIVE, it covers 39% of all ppl taking the test (based on last years hsc scaling report), i think this should be a factor too
I just searched this up and you're actually right. That fact is quite surprising when you consider that it is greater than the E4 percentage of all other math courses.

In that case, while the difficulty of the hardest few questions is somewhat less than previous years creating the impression of an easier exam, they may still all be above the band 6 threshold. It is possible then for the band 6 cutoff to be similar to previous years as a student between band 5 and 6 would be "just" unable to do all of 14a. In effect, the average and distribution of E4s could be towards higher marks, yet the cutoff still could be lowered. That is a little weird.
 
Joined
Oct 31, 2020
Messages
74
Gender
Male
HSC
2020
I just searched this up and you're actually right. That fact is quite surprising when you consider that it is greater than the E4 percentage of all other math courses.

In that case, while the difficulty of the hardest few questions is somewhat less than previous years creating the impression of an easier exam, they may still all be above the band 6 threshold. It is possible then for the band 6 cutoff to be similar to previous years as a student between band 5 and 6 would be "just" unable to do all of 14a. In effect, the average and distribution of E4s could be towards higher marks, yet the cutoff still could be lowered. That is a little weird.
yeah, like i can see this having several 'peaks' as it were, one from 65-70 and another falling smack in the middle of the e4 cutoff ie 50-57

but personally idk if this will 'lower' the cutoff compared to previous years im not all over this
 

Husky

Active Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2019
Messages
108
Gender
Male
HSC
2019
yeah, like i can see this having several 'peaks' as it were, one from 65-70 and another falling smack in the middle of the e4 cutoff ie 50-57

but personally idk if this will 'lower' the cutoff compared to previous years im not all over this
Its largely unpredictable tbh
 

Xanthi

Active Member
Joined
Jul 4, 2020
Messages
208
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2020
yeah, like i can see this having several 'peaks' as it were, one from 65-70 and another falling smack in the middle of the e4 cutoff ie 50-57

but personally idk if this will 'lower' the cutoff compared to previous years im not all over this
Yeah that multiple peak theory sounds the most compatible with the perception of this exam and math extension 2 as well. The average won't be in the middle of e4 (it never is) but I see a 40-45 median with 50-55 e4 cutoff and another peak at 65-70 as reasonable given the new percentile data you found.
 

ThiccyPishy

New Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2019
Messages
1
Gender
Female
HSC
2020
Uni Grad
2025
This exam was so easy, I marked it against NGO and I should get 68/70. What does this scale to?
 

beetree1

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 10, 2019
Messages
539
Gender
Female
HSC
2020
This exam was so easy, I marked it against NGO and I should get 68/70. What does this scale to?
I wouldnt say it was easy, many people struggled with it so just shh
xanthi said 99 for 68 welldone!
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 2)

Top