variety of attitudes to war and how they changed over time (1 Viewer)

sarahberah

New Member
Joined
May 12, 2005
Messages
3
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
hey evry1

just wondering if any1 has some simple notes on the dot pt- "the variety of attitudes to the war and how they changed over time in Britain and Germany" it'd be really appreciated :) cant seem to find anything anywhere....

thanx
 

sarahberah

New Member
Joined
May 12, 2005
Messages
3
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
thanx :)

thanx alot! that did help heaps! (although the second attachment didn't work for some reason)


But do you know what the dot point is referring to when it says 'variety of attitudes'- does this just basically mean- the positive attitudes, the conscientious objectors and perhaps those who were undecided:confused:
 
Last edited:

hopeles5ly

Take Me Higher.
Joined
Aug 1, 2005
Messages
2,796
Location
Sydney
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
Germany:
Before:
-The war on two fronts resulted in the thinking of a purely defensive war were they’re defending their honor. thus boosted a lot of morale in german soliders.

After:
Soldiers:
- Lost of faith in leaders due to the battle of “Verdun and the Somme” as the same tactics particularly attrition were being used over and over, which just resulted more lots of casualties
- War weariness due to reality of war and trenches
Homefront
- Political unity, which Germany had, began to crack in 1917 for various reasons
- ‘Turnip winter’ and food shortages of 1916-1917, naval blockage created fury in the mass as much was affected. (Contributed to this split of political unity)
- Peace movements and strikes held in Berlin became more common
- Mass wanted political reform
- Socialist stop supporting war effort
- For this Led by social democrats, the parties of the left argued that if political reforms was not forthcoming, the government could not count on the continuing support of the working class for the war effort.
- Reichstag also demanded political reform
- 1918 Germany was close to a revolution and abdication of Kaiser seemed inevitable

- Britain:
Before:
- Met with enthusiasm and patriotic fervor
- Majority thought it be over by Christmas (Quick war to end all wars)
- Enthusiasm lasted for two yrs at there was massive enlistments in 1914/15
- Enlistments due to Lord Kitcheners great recruitment drives


After:
-Reality of war was different from image that was portrayed
-Pointlessness as they began to question the worth of war due to the causalities
-Wilson Owen wrote to his mother saying that he had to censor all his men’s letter because they wanted peace and were sick of war
- Back at the home front there was a Drop in voluntary recruitment after seeing the film of the Battle of the Somme. This also resulted in fainting, screaming and soldiers on leave crying.
- The members of the Union of Democratic Control which opposed war rose to 650 000 in 1917
- After the reality was exposed, civilians were horrified and were no longer enthusiastic
- Patience disappearing as they questioned simple matters especially in trenches.
- Addition of the war 3rd yr almost every family lost a love one which lead to war weariness.

if you get a question about the changing attitudes of the war talk about things such as the French Mutines, Britian, Germany, factors which contributed to changing attitudes such as the Battle of the Somme, life in trenches, economic hardships at the homefront etc.. i had all these ideas when i did my first source based assessment, got the question i wanted but totally forgot to mension most of the things listed above ><". variety of attitudes i THINK refers to the range of reactions to the war.
 
L

lilsxcwog69

Guest
Here it is , sorry

CHANGING ATTITUDES OF SOLDIERS ON THE WAR OVER TIME

BRITAIN

 Initial attitudes of soldiers to war were enthusiastic, positive and patriotic.
 Civilians eagerly rushed to join up (Especially in Britain where recruitment was voluntary.
 The enthusiasm changed by last years of the war as several memoirs show.
 Battle of the Somme was disastrous for British but still held their confidence about ultimate end of the war.
 Around Passchendaele 1917 war weariness definitely kicked in, troops lost their faith and resorted to a state of bitterness and disillusionment.
 Increasing disorder among soldiers on the Front. Incidences of self – inflicted wounds increased as war went on.
 Longer soldiers served in trenches strong attitudes of comradeship between troops and alienation from people at home.

GERMANY

 Germany had long tradition of conscription so it had no problem in its supply of cavalry.
 Germans held the same views and became themselves tired and lethargic as the war went on. Their reasons behind the enthusiasm to go to war no longer existed.
 Longer soldiers served in trenches strong attitudes of comradeship between troops and alienation from people at home.

CHRISTMAS TRUCE OF 1914

 Unofficial truce occurred on some parts of Western Front. Men from both Allied and German sides played sports and exchanged small luxuries.
 Some truces lasted for a few days. Commanders frowned on it thinking it would reduce aggressiveness when troops returned for battle.
 Attempts to repeat similar Christmas truces in 1915 were inevitably opposed.

NIVELLE MUTINY 1917

 General Nivelles disastrous offensives in mid 1917 caused 27, 00 French soldiers to leave trenches in an act of mutiny.
 Other troops attempted similar actions before punishment and improved treatment caused mutinies to collapse. British troops also rioted in late 1917.
 

Cindi_99

New Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2005
Messages
10
Location
Next Door...
Gender
Female
HSC
2006

sarahberah

New Member
Joined
May 12, 2005
Messages
3
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
thanx evry1 :)

WOW! thanx every1! thats helped alot!

anything i could help with?
 

hopeles5ly

Take Me Higher.
Joined
Aug 1, 2005
Messages
2,796
Location
Sydney
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
Cindi_99 said:
Looks like you have heaps of notes! There is a doco serises on the ABC about WW1 its on Wednesdays 10:35pm. Unfortunately for me, i started watching last week.. which was episode 5! I think this week is the Somme and Verdun. http://www.abc.net.au/tv/guide/netw/200601/programs/ZY7111A007D18012006T224500.htmhttp://www.abc.net.au/tv/guide/netw/200601/programs/ZY7111A008D25012006T224500.htmhttp://www.abc.net.au/tv/guide/netw/200602/programs/ZY7111A009D1022006T224500.htm
haha i dont find them docos very interesting ..
 
L

lilsxcwog69

Guest
Provide and overview of tactics and strategies used during WWI to break the stalemate (We are given 2 sources)

Are these notes adaqueate for a Q2

STRATEGIES AND TACTICS USED TO BREAK STALEMATE

STRATEGIES

 Opening up new fronts – Easterners in Britain wanted to open other fronts against the Central Powers. 1915 Gallipoli Campaign launched to put this strategy into practice. It involved putting Turkey out of the war in order to supply large Russian armies. (hence putting pressure on Germany’s Eastern Front)
 By end of the campaign result for Allies was disastrous. Other fronts developed in Italy and Salonika quickly developed into stalemates but had little impact on the war.
 Attrition – Gradually wearing down the opposition until it had run out of cavalry, resources or the will to maintain the war effort.
 On Western Front strategy of attrition resulted to simply killing men.

TACTICS

ARTILERY TACTICS

 Preparatory Bombardment - bombard enemy defences with all available heavy artillery. The idea was that this preliminary bombardment would either kill the defending soldiers or would at least force them to retreat
 Creeping Barrage - infantry advances behind moving curtain of artillery fire.
 Fire and Manoeuvre - Pairs of soldiers ‘leapfrog’ into attack – one provides covering fire while the other advances; then roles reverse. Required good training

INFANTRY TACTICS

 Bite and Hold tactics - Attackers use speed, surprise and small self-contained assault groups to occupy limited section of enemy trenches, then hold them against counterattacks.
 Leapfrogging - Bite and Hold tactics repeatedly used to move from objective to next objective.

TECHNOLOGY

 Closely related to tactics as it was implemented into new and old tactics
 Gas – (64 Types) German Army first used chlorine gas cylinders in April 1915 against the French Army at Ypres. It destroyed the respiratory organs of its victims and this led to a slow death by asphyxiation
 Increased the army's range of attack and helped to protect their own troops when weather conditions were not completely ideal.
 Flamethrowers - used pressurised air, carbon dioxide or nitrogen to force oil through a nozzle. Ignited by a small charge, the oil became a jet of flame.
 First used on Western Front on October 1914 by German Army only effective over narrow areas of No Man's Land.

IM POSTING UP MY MODERN NOTES ON SOME TOPICS
 

Cindi_99

New Member
Joined
Oct 20, 2005
Messages
10
Location
Next Door...
Gender
Female
HSC
2006
hopeles5ly said:
haha i dont find them docos very interesting ..
i have never watched an interesting history doco, i dun think they exist! truth be told, i had to tape it coz i was starting to fall asleep...

AHH! reading all these notes, i think i need to get a move on with mine.
 

hopeles5ly

Take Me Higher.
Joined
Aug 1, 2005
Messages
2,796
Location
Sydney
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
Cindi_99 said:
i have never watched an interesting history doco, i dun think they exist! truth be told, i had to tape it coz i was starting to fall asleep...

AHH! reading all these notes, i think i need to get a move on with mine.
i wrote all mine and memorized them all for my first assessment which was on the last week of school !. now ive forgotten them all -___-" hehe. i can't wait to start the next topic -- GERMANY ! i hated ww1 ..
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top